My Early Experiments with Digital Symphonic Music
One of my symphonic compositions began as nothing more than a test: a plain melody I wrote to hear how a new set of orchestral samples sounded. Fifty-two versions later, it had become Experience #52, released on my album Prologue in 2007. Behind that number lie countless hours spent working with orchestral arrangements, sampled instruments and the possibilities of computer-based music production. I was trying to achieve something that, with the equipment available to me at the time, was surprisingly difficult: a reasonably convincing orchestral sound. But the story began several years earlier.
AMD K6, Cubase VST 5 and Sound Blaster Live!
My interest in creating symphonic music with digital instruments dates back to the late 1990s. By 2000, I was seriously involved in this direction. That year, I purchased a personal computer equipped with an AMD K6 processor and running Windows 98. My music software was Steinberg Cubase VST 5, which worked reasonably well on that machine. I also purchased a 15-inch CRT monitor and a Creative Sound Blaster Live! sound card, and ordered a four-octave MIDI keyboard, which took about a month to arrive. Altogether, my first computer-based music setup cost approximately $830, as far as I can remember.
The software offered plenty of opportunities to experiment with arrangements. The real problem was the sound. The orchestral instruments available to me were rather primitive. Strings, brass and other acoustic instruments often sounded flat, artificial and almost plastic. They lacked the depth and natural variation that make an acoustic instrument expressive. A musical passage could work perfectly well in terms of melody, harmony and arrangement, yet sound completely unconvincing when played back through those instruments.
Still, I enjoyed the process enormously. I could spend hours developing melodies, arranging instrumental parts and trying different combinations of sounds. Sometimes I worked until four in the morning. During that period, I created numerous sketches and quite a few complete compositions. Some of their melodies, motifs and arrangement ideas have stayed with me to this day. I was reluctant, however, to present those recordings to professional musicians. I believed some of the musical material deserved attention, but the instrumental sound was simply not good enough.
2001: The Lost Archive
In 2001, practically everything I had created on that computer disappeared. I gave the machine to a technician who was supposed to reinstall Windows. Naturally, I was concerned about my music files, but he assured me that they would be preserved. I trusted him. When the computer was returned, the musical projects were gone. Everything had been erased. His explanation amounted to little more than: “Oh, I’m sorry.”
I had already spent hundreds of hours on those compositions. The lost files contained arrangements, instrumental parts, musical sketches and countless details that had taken considerable time to develop. And suddenly, none of it was there. Some melodies and ideas remained in my memory, of course. But remembering a composition is not the same as having the original project, with all its instrumental parts and carefully adjusted details. Reconstructing everything would have meant doing much of the work again. After that incident, my enthusiasm for digital symphonic music declined considerably.
That same year, I bought another computer, this time equipped with an Intel Celeron processor. Soon afterwards, I travelled from Riga to Moscow to buy a new five-octave MIDI keyboard at A&T Trade. The company’s Riga branch offered a rather limited choice of MIDI keyboards at the time, so I went to Russia myself. Unfortunately, the new computer brought a different problem: severe crackling during audio playback. Despite repeated attempts, I was never able to eliminate it. After just a few months, I sold the computer.
It was one more disappointment. First the lost archive, then the unconvincing sound of the orchestral instruments, and now a computer that could not play music without crackling. By that point, I had lost much of my motivation to continue experimenting with digital symphonic music. However, I did not stop composing. I continued producing electronic music, particularly ambient and new-age compositions, just as intensively as before. It was specifically symphonic music that moved into the background for several years.
2006: A Disc from Moscow
Things began to change in 2006. A friend brought me a disc from Moscow containing samples of classical orchestral instruments. Compared with the sounds I had used around 2000, these were noticeably better. For the first time in several years, I felt encouraged to return to my orchestral experiments. The improvement was significant, although the results still left much to be desired.
Separately from my orchestral experiments, I also began receiving music commissions from the United Kingdom in 2006. These projects were unrelated to symphonic music. They involved creating and adapting instrumental music to fit vocal recordings sent to me.
My music production setup had expanded considerably since those early experiments. I now had more musical equipment, more powerful computers and a much wider range of software instruments and recording tools. It was a far more serious setup, and yet it did not remove the central problem. I was becoming increasingly aware that achieving a convincing instrumental performance involved much more than selecting a suitable sound. An acoustic instrument changes its character depending on how it is played. The strength of an attack, the duration of a note, transitions between notes and the movement of a musical phrase all affect the result. Sampled instruments could reproduce certain aspects of this behaviour, but much of the musical expression still had to be developed manually. I often found myself adjusting individual passages, reconsidering instrumental balances and modifying arrangements to compensate for the limitations of the sounds. And it was with these new samples that the story of Experience #52 actually began.
From Experience #1 to Experience #52
There was no artistic concept at the beginning. I simply needed to hear how the new samples behaved, so I sketched a plain, unpretentious melody, just something to play through different instruments and see what they could do. That test melody became Experience #1.
But a test rarely stays a test. I added another part to see how a different instrument would sit alongside the first. Then another. A second theme appeared, then a third, each written in the language of the score I had learned from classical music: voices, entrances, the balance between them. The melody acquired company. Gradually, what had been a single thread began to weave itself into a larger fabric.
There was rarely a clear point at which I felt everything was finished. Sometimes the balance between instruments needed adjustment. At other times, a passage did not sound the way I imagined it, or I wanted to try a different arrangement. I would make changes, listen to the result, and eventually return to the project again. With every version, the piece felt fuller and more complete. Several themes had grown together into one composition, and each revision brought their relationships into sharper focus, both in the score and in the sound. Yet it never satisfied me completely.
I realise that fifty-two versions may sound excessive. But I was not simply correcting mistakes in something I had planned. The composition was growing in front of me, and I was trying to narrow the distance between the music I could hear in my imagination and what the digital instruments could actually reproduce. Not every revision was a new arrangement; many were part of a continuing search for better instrumental sounds and a more convincing whole.
Eventually, I decided to leave the composition in its fifty-second version. The finished work was titled Experience #52 and was released on my album Prologue in 2007. I kept the number in the title. I kept the number in the title because it had become part of the composition’s history.
Beyond My Studio
The composition later found its way into two other projects. It was included in Cloudwalk CD, a music compilation released by Helmar Rudolph. In 2011, videographer Daniel Santos used Experience #52 in his time-lapse film Fort de Lippe / Forte da Graça, featuring the historic fortress near Elvas, Portugal. The film was created from approximately 4,000 photographs rather than conventional video footage, with a camera dolly providing smooth movement throughout the sequences.
What Those Years Taught Me
Looking back, I realise that the search for better orchestral samples was only part of the challenge. My work was always happening on two levels at once: the score, with its themes, voices and structure, and the sound, with its samples, balance and texture. The limitations of the instruments forced me to examine both more carefully.
When a passage sounded unconvincing, I had to determine whether the problem lay in the sound, the arrangement or the interaction between instrumental parts. Sometimes changing an instrument was enough, but often the phrase itself or the balance of an entire section needed reconsidering. I also became accustomed to working on individual passages independently rather than always proceeding from the beginning of a composition to the end. I could return to a particular section, change a few details, listen again and decide whether the result was closer to what I wanted. It was a slow process, but it became a natural way for me to work with music.
Fifty-Two Versions Later
More than two decades have passed since those early experiments with Cubase VST 5, my AMD K6 computer and Sound Blaster Live!. Digital music technology has changed enormously, and sounds that were once beyond my reach are now much more accessible. But despite the limited computing power, the small selection of MIDI keyboards and the lack of good orchestral samples, those were wonderful times. There was a sense of momentum, a kind of living energy, and I was determined to bring my musical ideas to life. I still remember those long nights, the disappointment of losing my earliest archive, and the plain little melody that was only meant to test some samples.
I could probably have continued revising it indefinitely. There would always have been another sound to try, another detail to adjust or another arrangement to reconsider. But at some point, a composition has to be allowed to exist as it is. And whenever I see that number in its title, I remember how much time and experimentation can lie behind a few minutes of music. Experience #52 also became the starting point for my further work in digital symphonic music.
Andrei Gulaikin (aka Gulan)